Your renewal packet just landed, and the number went up — again. Before anyone signs anything, here are the 8 questions that decide whether it's actually a fair price. I ask them for clients every day. Now you have them too.
Ask for the increase split out: medical trend, pharmacy, your group's own claims experience. "Costs went up" is not an explanation; it's a shrug.
Deductibles, copays, out-of-pocket maxes, prescription tiers. A "small" increase that also doubled the deductible can be a worse deal than a big one that changed nothing.
Networks shrink quietly. Check the doctors your employees actually use — before the paperwork, not after the first complaint.
The question most owners never get answered. Comparable groups your size get quoted all day. If nobody shopped it for you this year, you didn't get a renewal — you got an invoice.
Low usage might mean a richer plan than your people need. High usage might mean a plan design that's costing you more, not less. Utilization data decides whether to shop, redesign — or genuinely stay put.
HSA-compatible plans, HRAs, different funding arrangements. Sometimes the answer isn't a new carrier — it's a different shape of plan that costs less and covers your people better.
Quotes take weeks, and your decision usually lands 30–60 days before the effective date. The work starts about 120 days before renewal — that's where the leverage is.
It's a legal requirement for brokers to disclose their compensation — so asking is normal, and a straightforward answer is a good sign. Silence or a runaround is worth noticing.
All 8 questions as a clean one-page checklist you can keep in the renewal folder — plus a short plain-English heads-up before renewal season each year. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
The free review does all 8 for your business: your plan compared to the market, every option side by side, in plain English.